Very interesting and thought provoking thread/comments. I've been working Woodbine and in the short field top class, one, it's temporary, so people grab while the grabbing is good. Two, for me, I am looking to beat the favorite and if I can't, it's better next time, LOL. While the traditional handicap might not be a true handicap, why not do it. Sure. People can argue all day long that it might help this horse or that horse, but that's why the run the races. Might. LOL. Good idea.